Jump to content

Photo
- - - - -

Advantage CP

counterplans advantage policyd debate neg

  • Please log in to reply
4 replies to this topic

#1 Isbrar

Isbrar

    Novice

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 8 posts
1
Okay
  • Name:Ishaan
  • School:Stockdale

Posted 13 February 2018 - 01:10 PM

How do I stop the aff from perming an advantage cp. can they even perm or is there I card or something I can read
  • 0

#2 TheSnowball

TheSnowball

    Hall of Fame

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,859 posts
1,243
Excellent
  • Name:Ryan

Posted 13 February 2018 - 04:40 PM

The idea of the CP is that it neutralizes an advantage. Whether the judge votes Affirmative or Negative, that impact is solved. You should run the CP with a net-benefit that links to the plan but NOT the CP.

So if the plan is to fund STEM and it solves the economy and global warming, maybe you read advantage CPs that do a tax cut to solve the economy and plant solar panels to solve warming. Then you read a federalism DA.

World in which the plan is passed: economy solved (good), warming solved (good), federalism wrecked (bad).

World in which the CP is passed: economy solved (good), warming solved (good).

But doing BOTH the plan and the CP does not have an additional benefit. World in which both are passed: economy solved (good), warming solved (good), federalism wrecked (bad). The economy and warming can't be "double solved" because either the plan or CP can independently sufficiently solve to avert the impact.

Or, say you don't run a DA. You read the solar panels CP and you impact-turn the economy by saying growth destroys the environment.

World of plan: warming solved (good), economy solved (bad).

World of CP: warming solved (good).

World of both: warming solved (good), economy solved (bad).

The point is that the permutation links to the net-benefit while the CP alone does not, while still sufficiently solving and thereby neutralizing Affirmative offense.

Make sense?
  • 2

Daily Evidence Card!
Exodus Files!

This cross-ex is taking too long.

Kafka 25 (Franz, Novelist, Translated by David Wyllie, "The Trial", 1925) //Snowball

K. was informed by telephone that there would be a small hearing concerning his case the following Sunday. He was made aware that these cross examinations would follow one another regularly, perhaps not every week but quite frequently. On the one hand it was in everyone’s interest to bring proceedings quickly to their conclusion, but on the other hand every aspect of the examinations had to be carried out thoroughly without lasting too long because of the associated stress. For these reasons, it had been decided to hold a series of brief examinations following on one after another. Sunday had been chosen as the day for the hearings so that K. would not be disturbed in his professional work. It was assumed that he would be in agreement with this, but if he wished for another date then, as far as possible, he would be accommodated. Cross-examinations could even be held in the night, for instance, but K. would probably not be fresh enough at that time. Anyway, as long as K. made no objection, the hearing would be left on Sundays. It was a matter of course that he would have to appear without fail, there was probably no need to point this out to him. He would be given the number of the building where he was to present himself, which was in a street in a suburb well away from the city centre which K. had never been to before.


#3 NickDB8

NickDB8

    Exodus Files Forum Representative

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 692 posts
453
Excellent
  • Name:Nick
  • School:Emporia HS

Posted 13 February 2018 - 06:37 PM

Just read politics and a solar panels CP bc lol why would solar panels link to politics?
  • 3

Exodus Files - Updated 5/21! Grab our new STEM Affirmative for the upcoming education topic!

Research Tools


#4 TheSnowball

TheSnowball

    Hall of Fame

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,859 posts
1,243
Excellent
  • Name:Ryan

Posted 13 February 2018 - 07:25 PM

Just read politics and a solar panels CP bc lol why would solar panels link to politics?

Don't mock me, Nick, I made a mistake that day and you don't have to remind me.


  • 2

Daily Evidence Card!
Exodus Files!

This cross-ex is taking too long.

Kafka 25 (Franz, Novelist, Translated by David Wyllie, "The Trial", 1925) //Snowball

K. was informed by telephone that there would be a small hearing concerning his case the following Sunday. He was made aware that these cross examinations would follow one another regularly, perhaps not every week but quite frequently. On the one hand it was in everyone’s interest to bring proceedings quickly to their conclusion, but on the other hand every aspect of the examinations had to be carried out thoroughly without lasting too long because of the associated stress. For these reasons, it had been decided to hold a series of brief examinations following on one after another. Sunday had been chosen as the day for the hearings so that K. would not be disturbed in his professional work. It was assumed that he would be in agreement with this, but if he wished for another date then, as far as possible, he would be accommodated. Cross-examinations could even be held in the night, for instance, but K. would probably not be fresh enough at that time. Anyway, as long as K. made no objection, the hearing would be left on Sundays. It was a matter of course that he would have to appear without fail, there was probably no need to point this out to him. He would be given the number of the building where he was to present himself, which was in a street in a suburb well away from the city centre which K. had never been to before.


#5 Isbrar

Isbrar

    Novice

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 8 posts
1
Okay
  • Name:Ishaan
  • School:Stockdale

Posted 14 February 2018 - 10:20 AM

Thx. That makes sense
  • 0





Similar Topics Collapse


Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: counterplans, advantage, policyd debate, neg

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users