Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


ShreeBuck last won the day on June 25 2019

ShreeBuck had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

-1 Slipping...

About ShreeBuck

  • Rank
    Longtime Member
  • Birthday 07/16/1994

Profile Information

  • Name
  • School
  • Location

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. God what the hell are you doing on here Ivan

  2. so you're the other one

  3. ShreeBuck

    deer park 09

    Yup, but they like to refer to themselves as the "KS Debate team", so I decided to honor that.
  4. ShreeBuck

    deer park 09

    Quarters: Woodlands NW d. Clear Lake JC Clear Lake DL d. Hendrickson AD Clear Lake KS d. ??? Crosby DS d. Clear Lake KS Note: There are two Clear Lake KS teams. Semis: Woodlands NW d. Clear Lake DL Clear Lake KS d. Crosby DS Finals: Clear Lake KS d. Woodlands NW
  5. The only time I've hit a Delay CP was last year around when the Elections DA was popular. The counterplan text was to do the plan...on November the 5th. I personally think that they're illegit considering the fact that they sever out of the immediacy of the plan, and as the aff we have to defend the immediacy of the plan, it should be reciprocal imo, like I feel it's a question of whether the plan should pass or shouldn't pass. Not when it should pass. Secondly, the neg just takes on the aff advocacy and makes the aff defend against their own advocacy, which I find stupid and annoying. Next time though, ask Rahim or Wilbur these types of questions than asking random people on a debate forum.
  6. Actually Andrew, the judge referenced the questions the other team had asked during the post-1NC CX as examples as to why "revolutionary ethic" was better.
  7. I usually read the "do nothing" alternative for cap, but this past weekend at Grapevine, after reading cap, a judge recommended I read the "revolutionary ethic" alternative because it the alternative debate isn't as messy as it would be with "do nothing", like 'Isn't doing nothing really doing something?' or 'How does the alternative solve the case', and allows you to avoid the vague alternatives bad theory, etc. He also said that Zizek was the author of the card, though he couldn't remember the year, book/article, or anything. So I guess my questions are as follows: What is the "revolutionary ethic" alternative? How does it avoid messy alternative debates associated with "do nothing"? Finally, what's the card? Any and all help is appreciated.
  8. Thanks, whichever team ran CAFOs is what I was looking for.
  9. It would be nice if someone could post cites for their CAFOs aff from last year, or explain to me how to look at the college case list's archives.
  10. Breaks, courtesy of Bill Batterman of the 3NR. Double-Octafinals–3:00PM Bronx Science ME vs. College Prep CM — Petit, Sanchez, Carswell Carrollton DG vs. Dulles KC — Greenstein, Peretz, Koo Chattahoochee CR vs. Kinkaid KB — Marks, Rubaie, Sabino College Prep YP vs. St. Paul Central QJ — Crowe, Iola, Schultz Coppell KD vs. Law Magnet CS — Davis, Gaston, Gagnon Damien EG vs. Glenbrook South MZ — Kall, Duffy, Baker Glenbrook North PS vs. Westminster DM — Powell, Grusin, Quinn Glenbrook North SM (aff) vs. Westminster MC — Bricker, Levkovitz, Abelkop Glenbrook South TD vs. Bellaire LQ — Osborn, Mahoney, Carver Grapevine QS vs. Damien VF — Mulholland, Heidt, Manuel Highland Park PY vs. Georgetown Day RS — Martin, Sharp, Turoff New Trier SC vs. St. Mark’s MB — Eyzaguirre, Hines, Lingel Westlake MB vs. Dallas Jesuit DG — Jagneaux, Querido, Rowe Westminster TA vs. Bishop Guertin SD — Matheson, Tate, Peterson Whitney Young HG vs. Glenbrook South SV — Phillips, Batik, Batterman Woodward PP vs. Dallas Jesuit MY — Berthiaume, Smith, Tallungan
  11. Records thus far? Specifically, how USN BL, USN UR, and/or Calhoun BL are doing?
  12. Schopenhauer - assisted suicide/euthanasia
  • Create New...