Files posted by Shes legal in dog years
This is your basic churchill critique - the aff passes legislation on stolen land which reinforces genocide and exclusion which is sorta not good. the alternative is to vote not aff in order to endorse a larger call for the united states out of north america.
This critique will function excellent against critical cases and cases that read environment advantages. There is comparably good 1NC link evidence: “ let’s just dream that it’s been fulfilled. Things like racism, sexism, ageism, militarism, classism, and the sorts of corporatism with which we are now afflicted have been abolished. The police have been leashed and the prison-industrial complex dismantled. Income disparities have been eliminated across the board, decent housing and healthcare are available to all, an amply endowed educational system is actually devoted to teaching rather than indoctrinating our children. The whole nine yards.
Sound good? You bet. Nonetheless, there’s still a very basic—and I daresay uncomfortable—question which must be posed: In this seemingly rosy scenario, what, exactly, happens to the rights of native peoples? Face it, to envision the progressive transformation of “American society” is to presuppose that “America”—that is, the United States—will continue to exist. And, self-evidently, the existence of the United States is, as it has always been and must always be, predicated first and foremost on denial of the right of self-determining existence to every indigenous nation within its purported borders.”
I think you get the idea.
The 2NC at: section is small right now but i will be putting out updates throughout the year. Especially after camp/beginning of the year and after the first case lists come out.
It also includes a small framework file. I will make the framework bigger in the updates as well.
At 10 dollars you are getting a good, solid critique that will work every year and that will plain out win rounds. There was a reason that OU’s small squad made OU CJ good, and this argument was one of the tools in their arsenal for a reason.
I’ll make sure that all questions you have about the file after you purchase it are answered. I believe this argument will be extremely good for next year. after you win a round or 10 on it you will as well.
1NC SHELL 2-9
2NC LINK: LIBERATION/CHRISTIANITY 10-11
2NC LINK: GAY RIGHTS 12-13
2NC LINK - DICHOTOMOUS REASONING 14
2NC LINK - Hierarchies 15
2NC LINK—ODERED WORLD/IMPERIALISM 16
2NC LINK - LAW 17-20
2NC LINK - STATE 21
2NC LINK - LAW AS LIBERATION 22-23
2NC LINK - ECONOMY 24-25
2NC IMPACT- EUROCENTRISM TURNS THE AFF 26 2NC IMPACT - LAW = BAD 27-34
2NC IMPACT - ENVIRONMENT 35
2NC IMPACT - TIMEFRAME 36
AT: PERMUTATION- DO BOTH 37-39
AT: PERMUTATION - DO ALT/DOUBLE BIND 40
AT: PERMUTATION- DO PLAN THEN ALT 41
AT: PERMUTATION - PLAN AND USE THE BALLOT AS REJECTION 42
AT: PERMUTATION - GIVE BACK SACRED LANDS 43
AT: PERMUTATION - BEST AND KELNER 44
AT: REALISM GOOD 45-48
AT: LAW IS INEVITABLE 49
AT: ALTERNATIVE BANISHES WHITEY FROM AMERIKKKA 50
AT: ALT IS VAGUE THEORY 51
AT: ALT IS EMPERICALLY DENIED 52
AT: CRITIQUE OF IDENTITY TIED TO LAND 53
AT: MOVE OUT OF AMERICA 54
AT: ID POLITICS BAD 55
AT: ALT WILL LEAD TO GENOCIDE 56
AT: OTHERS WILL COLONIZE/WILL ATTACK/COL INEVITABLE 57
AT: STATE LEADS TO REFORM 58
AT: STATE GOOD 59-60
AT: NUCLEAR WAR WORSE/HEGEMONY IS GOOD 61-62
AT: NATIVES NOT HERE FIRST 63
AT: LINK OF OMISSION 64
AT: OUR -ISM/-OLOGY COMES FIRST 65
AT: IMPACTS SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED/NO THRESHOLD 66
AT: PRAGMATISM GOOD 67
AT: ZIZEK/LETTER OF THE LAW 68
AT: CAP COMES FIRST 69
AT: BIODIVERSITY 70
AT: NO UNIQUE LINK 71
AT: ‘NEED REAL ALT’ THEORY/RORTY 72-73
AT: WEST IS BEST 74
BEST 2NC CARD TO READ AGAINST RADICAL CASES/ENVIRONMENT ADV. CASES 75-76
NEGATIVE FRAMEWORK 77
AT: SIMULATION GOOD 78-79
AT: FIAT KEY TO EDUCATION 80
LEGISLATING FOR OTHERS BAD 81-82
QUESTIONING COMES FIRST 83
EXPERT KNOWLEDGE BAD 84
NAZI DOCTOR 85
DISCOURSE FIRST 86-87
DIS-AD TO POLICY SIMULATION 88
AT: FAIRNESS KEY 89
AT: EDUCATION KEY 90
AT: PREDICTABILITY KEY 91
AT: WRONG FORUM 92
Table of Contents
People have been having touble finding new things to run against military cases like end strength, dadt or women in combat. This Disadvantage, relying on the "horror" of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is great when coupled with things like Chaloupka, Militarism, or anything with an anti-extinction/probabalistic framework (not to mention at NFLs you'll have conservative judges that will prefer a "realistic disadvantage"). This File is an extremeley well-blocked out (just look at the TOC) and lay/conservative friendly (while still having a lot of strategical value).
Table of Contents
These are some of the best answers to Nietzschean affirmatives and critiques i have ever read or seen. I am 98% sure they have never been read in High School debate and actually has a great answer to the permutation. I won't say anything about the critique aside from the fact that it can be redone as a 2AC permutation if you so desire. IM me at thatnerdtommy if you want help structuring that. I promise that this will be the best 5 dollars you have ever spent on a Nietzsche file that you will ever spend. These cares are AMAZING. They assume negative/affirmative answers while also paiting a picture of what the world truley looks like.
This is a 50 page theory file inluding fiat good/bad. For the most part all the frontlines are ready to go, you might want to read over them in-case i messed up on changing them over to National Service because its the theory file i used in my last 2 years of debate.
For a file that you will be able to use EVERY round, aff and neg, and EVERY topic from Novice to College, its a steal at 5 dollars.
This is a generic criticism of trying to "queer the Military" so to speak. Trying to use institutions like the military or the goverment fails because the movement will become co-opted. There are a few individual criticisms of Gay movements within society and within the military in each card such as:
-the homosexual as the "stranger"
-women and men of color within the gay movement that get marganlized
-militarism, oppression, and violence.
You're alternative is to refuse citizenship and instead attempt to make the law Queer.
There is a full 2NC overview and answers to Perm: Do Both and Link Turns [general]. The file itself is kinda disorganized but only because i want you to read the cards before using the file.
If you have questions, PM me or AIM me [thatnerdtommy]
Oh, and this is one of those files that you can also use on any topic or against any affirmative that trys to expand gay-rights if you re-highlight the evidence. Its worth it to have just in-case.
Just your general politics update. The focus is on Jackson-vanik rather than immigration though. Have fun. For $1 its a hell of a deal for some great uniqueness answers to Jackson-Vanik.