Jump to content
lfpnub

lfpnub v Arrow1124 / GracchusBabeuf

Recommended Posts

1. Can you explain your impact scenario?

2. Can you explain how infrastructure of the school affects student learning?

3. Is this plan popular for the GOP?

4. Can you explain how the plan does enough to cause a large enough change?

5. How does the plan solve for inequality and racism?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. There are 2. For one, squo toxins disproportionately affect poor and minority students in the squo, and that causes respiratory illnesses, mental health issues, and generally screws with health

 

2. Crampton and Cohen are pretty good on this- if your school is freezing and has bad AC, you're essentially being forced to learn outside. Also, bad air can cause lower attendance and slower task speed 

 

3. I don't know, there isn't really a study on how much the GOP  likes school buildings, so I cannot say.

 

4. Sure. Crampton says that infrastructure is more important in the educational process than teacher retention, and the Rettner card

 

5. Memmi framing means as long as we partially solve racism, as in our Millman 2/1 card, we can access the framing. We do not need to win total solvency of all of racism, just that the plan is a step in the right direction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the world of the alt, does the state exist? If so, then how is the alt another way of justifying squo political organization. If not, then what state does the party take over?

How does the aff increase the rejection of students by the system as described in the Hill and Kumar ev? Doesn't the aff increase opportunity?

Doesn't the Battistoni card conclude  "The Left should be making this argument explicitly too — but to people who are most likely to be affected by the prospect of a bad century. We should be talking not just about fossil-fuel infrastructure, but about ownership of capital as the power to shape the future."- how do you access this card if it says that we need to use cap to shape future.

 What does the world of the alt look like? 

How does creating a party actually solve the impacts?

How does the party avoid co-option like what actually happened to China?

 

Status of the offcase positions?
 How is the aff identity politics?

Isn't the article to the midterms DA only talking about  uneducated people voted Trump? If so, then why doesn't the aff's education solve this?

Where is the increasing education helps trump warrant?

Where is the warrant in the Hellman and Bender card that says that trump's empowerment kills IMF- why wouldn't trump ignore the Hawks?
Aren't there other things that empower trump, like immigration policy?

 

What's the link to Islamaphobia DA?

How does the aff use the prison system?

How does the squo solve structural violence in the context of the conceded Millman and Rettner cards?

How does the travel ban not thump your Islamophobia DA? 

How is increasing funding not an increase?

What program is the aff creating?

How does a state circumvent money that is tied to infrastructure improvement?

How do understanding from teachers, insufficient time to understand new educational strategies, professional development, or school capacity affect the rebuilding of schools themselves- aren't these in the context of teacher training?

EDIT: Formatting/ complete sentences

Edited by lfpnub

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do y'all have a judge? Because the one y'all have listed hasn't been active in a while.

I hope we do

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Yes the state exist

2.we endorse a communist party to take over the usfg if that is what your asking.

3.the alt rejects the neoliberal ideas that the aff pushes and works on destroying capitalism.

4. The aff's opportunities are for the labor market as schools are being used to make workers for the labor market

5.the card isn't saying That capitalism is necessary to shape the future

6. The card isnt saying that cap is necessary it's saying it's being used

7.we would educate people with the mindset of capitalism must die and transform them to communist and teach them to support the communist party.

8.once the communist party takes over we transform the USA to a communist nation.

9.we don't allow for revisionist in the party

10.conditional

11. The aff focus on race instead of class to solve for racism

12.that's not what the card is saying at all its talking about support of education policies.

13.the second card on the midterms da

14. In the beginning of the card it says that the GOP is pushing trump to leave the inf and with the political capital of the plan he leaves the inf

15.don't know

16.the aff using the security state pushes the oppression of Muslims

17.the usfg is the security state

18.the squo doesn't solve only the alt can

19.the travel ban is an example on why the security state causes more oppression

20.your creating new funding not funding something that the USfg was already funding

21.the state uses the money to fund something else is one example

22.their context on how the school operates

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Yes the state exist

2.we endorse a communist party to take over the usfg if that is what your asking.

3.the alt rejects the neoliberal ideas that the aff pushes and works on destroying capitalism.

4. The aff's opportunities are for the labor market as schools are being used to make workers for the labor market

5.the card isn't saying That capitalism is necessary to shape the future

6. The card isnt saying that cap is necessary it's saying it's being used

7.we would educate people with the mindset of capitalism must die and transform them to communist and teach them to support the communist party.

8.once the communist party takes over we transform the USA to a communist nation.

9.we don't allow for revisionist in the party

10.conditional

11. The aff focus on race instead of class to solve for racism

12.that's not what the card is saying at all its talking about support of education policies.

13.the second card on the midterms da

14. In the beginning of the card it says that the GOP is pushing trump to leave the inf and with the political capital of the plan he leaves the inf

15.don't know

16.the aff using the security state pushes the oppression of Muslims

17.the usfg is the security state

18.the squo doesn't solve only the alt can

19.the travel ban is an example on why the security state causes more oppression

20.your creating new funding not funding something that the USfg was already funding

21.the state uses the money to fund something else is one example

22.their context on how the school operates

Few follow ups, 

on q3: how do you access the card if it concludes a certain way- how do you use capitalism to fight climate change?

on q14: Where's that PC warrant though- I haven't seen it? Could you pick it out from the card please?

on q7: Doesn't your alt text literally say: "Those revisionists who refuse to serve the party will be expunged, not educated"

on q8: but what if I don't wanna be a communist. What if I want to keep being capitalist, what happens to me?

on q11: how does a focus on class solve for racism?

on q15: isn't that what the link card for Islamaphobia calls the security state?

on q18: When did this DA get an alt?

 

on q19: Why hasn't the travel ban thumped your impacts?

on q21: How has your impact already not been triggered if any funding is a link? 

on q22: how does that have anything to do with inffrastructure

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted because IDK if ima be able to post in time after CX, so I'll just post now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

on question 3 the card concludes that in the status quo cap is shaping the future not that it is necessary to shape the future. the base of the card is the idea that the capitalist will do anything to keep capitalism alive and that is why the alt is important to destroy the capitalism. We don't use capitalism to stop climate change.

on question 14 . Leading Republican hawks are pushing legislation to compel Trump to take steps to develop new missiles in response — the first steps to jettisoning what is known as the INF treaty

 

on question 7 those who are trying to change the mindset or refuse it will be kicked out of the party. they won't be educated.

on question 8 your kicked out the party and not be educated

On question 11 capatilism is the root cause of racism and a understanding of the class system that is reproducing the racism and started it in the beginning is the best way to fight racism. To kill the weed you rip out its roots.

question 15 the usfg is the security state.

on question 18 i meant the alt on the maoism kritik

on question 19 the travel ban is a example of the security state and its prove of the da being true. 

on question 21 It has to be large involvement of the usfg like the aff.

on question 22 its saying that because of how the school is ran then the funding will never reach where its supposed to reach in this case the infrastructure

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

q 7 and 8:What happens after you're kicked out of the party? Do you just phase out of existence? Also, if you disagree with the party, why would you care whether or not you're in it?

Q11: Why is that the case

q14: Where's the empowered trump warrant tho? I saw that, but he never actually abolished the treaty.

q15: Where in the ev does it say the USFG is the security state? Because I only see specific security institutions.
Q18: Don't disads defend the status quo? Also doesn't your Mao K use the government as well?

q21: So something like the massive billion dollar spending bill passed earlier this year

q22: Where does it actually talk about infrastructure though- where's the contextualization to the aff?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×