Jump to content
NickDB8

Education vDebate - NickDB8 [A] vs The TrashDebater [N]

Recommended Posts

Why is federal funding key?

 

What standards does the aff create?

 

How is the offense under democracy unique under trump?

 

Why vote aff?

 

Why is US democracy good?

 

What benefit does state engagement give us?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why is federal funding key?

As per Avins, the NEA and NEH act as a "leveling force" ensuring equal access across the nation. Furthermore, Phenicie isolates that states can't pay for it on their own

 

What standards does the aff create?

Equal standards for access to high-quality A&H education

 

How is the offense under democracy unique under trump?

Trump provides UQ for the advantage - If anything, Trump proves the authoritarian leanings outlined in Kahlenberg

 

Why vote aff?

The plan is a good idea

 

Why is US democracy good?

It solves multiple scenarios for conflict, it's an impact filter, and, in context of the aff, reduces structural violence as per Eaude by combating things like stereotypes

 

What benefit does state engagement give us?

There's a couple -

1) It gives us an understanding of how the legal system works - That allows us as individuals to be ready to be policymakers in the future

2) Working within the state stops oppressive practices that happen within - The state isn't monolithic and always bad, there are things it can do that are good - Any kritik alt probably doesn't spill up into the USfg but the aff does which justifies a perm - That's Zanotti and Reitter

3) Refusing the state cedes power to the right, which is especially dangerous in the era of Trump - That's Boggs

 

edit: included the boggs stuff

Edited by NickDB8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What makes the plan a good idea?

 

So does the 1AC defend that the US has to be a leader in democracy, like what stops some other democratic nation from being able to take its place?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What makes the plan a good idea?

Our justification for the aff is outlined in the advantages

So does the 1AC defend that the US has to be a leader in democracy, like what stops some other democratic nation from being able to take its place?

The 1AC has two scenarios for democracy. First, is international democracy - That checks international conflict, and just needs a democratic leader, which doesn't necessarily have to be the US, but the second is domestic democracy - It's backsliding as per Kahlenberg and that's bad as per Kasparov

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cool, 1NC might take a bit but I’ll try to have it up by rye end of the weekend. I’m a bit busy sorry

It's all good!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One last question, does the aff try to make an emphasis on individualism via critical thought, if so, why is individualism good?

Edited by TheTrashDebater

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Order is three off and case. Label the flows K, CP DA. Then case is in the order of the 1AC. Word count is 2758, you can reciprocate in the 2AC if you want. I'm open for CX

 

 

1NC versus NickDB8.docx

 

 

EDIT: Forgot to attach the doc

Edited by TheTrashDebater

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One last question, does the aff try to make an emphasis on individualism via critical thought, if so, why is individualism good?

Not necessarily

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

CX -

 

Status of K and CP? Can you kick individual planks?

 

Is there an ethical reason to reject the aff?

 

What does the alt look like? Can the aff happen in the world of it? Do schools exist post alt?

 

Have the 50 states ever acted uniformly on anything?

 

In a world where your warming defense is true, why does federalism collapse matter?

 

Why does education federalism spill over to things like environment and energy policy?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

CX -

 

Status of K and CP? Can you kick individual planks?

 

Both are condo, I won’t kick planks

 

Is there an ethical reason to reject the aff?

 

Yes

 

What does the alt look like? Can the aff happen in the world of it? Do schools exist post alt?

 

The world of the alt is just Party consolidaticn.

 

No

 

Yes

 

Have the 50 states ever acted uniformly on anything?

 

Sure

 

In a world where your warming defense is true, why does federalism collapse matter?

 

I mean fed overreach still worsens models of equality and make schooling even worse

 

Why does education federalism spill over to things like environment and energy policy?

 

Think of fed like a dam, if you poke one small in it, the hole gets bigger and bigger as more things are justified

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Follow ups

 

CX -
 
Status of K and CP? Can you kick individual planks?

Both are condo, I won’t kick planks
 
Is there an ethical reason to reject the aff?

Yes

What is it?

What does the alt look like? Can the aff happen in the world of it? Do schools exist post alt?

The world of the alt is just Party consolidaticn.
What is party consolidation?
No

Yes

Have the 50 states ever acted uniformly on anything?

Sure

What's an example?

In a world where your warming defense is true, why does federalism collapse matter?

I mean fed overreach still worsens models of equality and make schooling even worse

Why does education federalism spill over to things like environment and energy policy?

Think of fed like a dam, if you poke one small in it, the hole gets bigger and bigger as more things are justified

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Cap invades our ethics and positions itself in the foundations of our society and to frame people as subjects of production that. It invades our ethical decisions to be more "economical" and more centered on the good of cap instead of what's good for the people

 

2. It's literally organizing class struggle into a political party

 

3. The Interstate Compact on Educational opportunity for Military Children

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's CX:

 

1. If we kick the CP does is theory still a voter?
 

2. If we provide a specific link to the plan for cap, does it get evaluated under your FW?

 

3. What do the worlds of the permutations look like?

 

4. Under your interpretation in FW does the K get evaluated?

 

 

 

Probably follow ups

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's CX:

 

1. If we kick the CP does is theory still a voter?

That's debatable, but as of now, sure

 

2. If we provide a specific link to the plan for cap, does it get evaluated under your FW?

Yes, links to the plan or advantages are legitimate

 

3. What do the worlds of the permutations look like?

On the CP -

Do Both is a form of cooperation between state and local governments

 

On the K -

Non-mutually exclusive parts would do the alt minus a rejection of the aff - Likely similar to do both

Do both does both - the Party gets formed and the plan is put in place

The curricular perm uses the A&H curriculum to promote the epistemology of the Party through A&H classes 

 

4. Under your interpretation in FW does the K get evaluated?

Yes

 

 

Probably follow ups

Edited by NickDB8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...