Surveillance- NativeWarlock (A) vs Luhan (N)

[NativeWarlock 192]

This'll be interesting. The 1AC won't be perfect, but ayyyy

Preciado 1AC.docx

Edited January 23, 2016 by NativeWarlock

[NativeWarlock 192]

Open for cx

[Taehyung 9]

What kind of surveillance is involved?

What is the impact?

What is the gender matrix?

What role does bio-power play in this?

What's bad about the status quo you describe?

Your second "Preciado" card says that bio-power is now "irreversible," so how can you fix it?

[NativeWarlock 192]

What kind of surveillance is involved?

Somatic policing

 

What is the impact?

The non-existance of our political subjectivity.

 

What is the gender matrix?

The capitalist projection of the male-female binary.

 

What role does bio-power play in this?

I mean the surveillance state controls our gender- that's control over our biology.

 

What's bad about the status quo you describe?

Gender binaries.

 

Your second "Preciado" card says that bio-power is now "irreversible," so how can you fix it?

The irreversible aspect is that of the techno-living. We think the 1ac isn't a question of how we curtail the techno-living's existance, rather how we orient ourselves to it. Edited January 23, 2016 by NativeWarlock

[NativeWarlock 192]

Also how bout some judges

[tommy949 449]

I would but I have no background on Precaido

[EndlessFacepalm 110]

I can judge, fine with anything, just impact out your offense to the framing, make the layers of the debate clear so I don't evaluate something that you think is on a lower level, (Kritiks), over something you think is on a higher level, (T/theory). I default to reasonability on T/Theory, but that's only if you don't give me another way to weigh. Please make interaction clear, I think that K vs K is terrible when noone does their work, but can be great if you make the effort required, so please explain interactions. I prefer good analysis and extensions on warrants over a dump of 20 new heg bad cards in response to a single heg good card. I think that using a single good warrant can beat back any number of cards, but, again, you need to do that work.
Any specific questions?

[NativeWarlock 192]

I would but I have no background on Precaido

Welcome to my world lol

[tommy949 449]

Welcome to my world lol

Then why are u running it?

[NativeWarlock 192]

Then why are u running it?

I've studied Preciado a lot just never translated it into a debate is what i meant, so we'll see how this goes

[Taehyung 9]

Another question, how do you plan to solve?

[Cakeisawesome12345 28]

also why does this 1ac look so familiar? Is it SVDPs?

[micahw 143]

This debate seems like it's going to be a lot of multi-syllabic jargon...

[Taehyung 9]

I can tell this is going to be a very interesting debate. I'm having a blast compiling this speech.

[NativeWarlock 192]

Another question, how do you plan to solve?

A few ways.

 

Preciado says that dis-identication is effective. This is when we realize how hegemonic classes represent us, and detach ourselves from this image. In this case, the self-experimentation of the AFF detaches itself from capitalism.

 

Preciado says that producing discourse within the academy is key to political autonomy- but the question is what type of discourse we produce. In order to mitigate gender binaries, our affirmation of gender hijacking is a mode of self-experimentation in which we wreck control over our bodies.

 

Halberstam says that just the idea of our affirmation is good- taking a risk on our discourse is better than stagnant politics that enforce gender violence.

[lbchuck1 256]

also why does this 1ac look so familiar? Is it SVDPs?

*Michigan KMs

[Taehyung 9]

Document stats isn't working, couldn't get the word count.

This is going to be a fun, fun round.

1NC Preciado Aff.docx

[Taehyung 9]

Open for CX.

[EndlessFacepalm 110]

BTW that's like 5 off lol, 3 T shells, a K? and a CP

[Taehyung 9]

BTW that's like 5 off lol, 3 T shells, a K? and a CP

Sounds about right.

[NativeWarlock 192]

Open for CX.

Substantially

if I curtail 29% of surveillance do you lose any off case positions??

 

How did the 1ac curtail less than 30%? (How can u prove it)

 

Curtail:

do we have to use the state to curtail surveillance?

 

Surveillance:

What's data?

 

The K;

How does the 1ac hinder te alt?

 

That WSM ev be like the State is sexist towards women- how does that account for transgender bodies?

 

The biopower link just says the state uses biopower... how the hell did the 1ac trigger more state-owned biopower?

 

What does the alt look like?

 

CP:

What's "E"?

 

How does one identify as E? (i mean like do we have to like re-do our birth certificates or...?)

 

Michigan Journal of Gender and Law says our passports could say we are E- do we have to rely on State issued articles to identify as one gender identity?

[kylerbuckner 1164]

the 1nc is 4095 words..

[NativeWarlock 192]

the 1nc is 4095 words..

Yeah i'll figure something out with the 2ac lol but i guess i'm chill with the 1nc..

[NativeWarlock 192]

I can judge, fine with anything, just impact out your offense to the framing, make the layers of the debate clear so I don't evaluate something that you think is on a lower level, (Kritiks), over something you think is on a higher level, (T/theory). I default to reasonability on T/Theory, but that's only if you don't give me another way to weigh. Please make interaction clear, I think that K vs K is terrible when noone does their work, but can be great if you make the effort required, so please explain interactions. I prefer good analysis and extensions on warrants over a dump of 20 new heg bad cards in response to a single heg good card. I think that using a single good warrant can beat back any number of cards, but, again, you need to do that work.

Any specific questions?

Anything specific you mean by "interaction" on the k vs k flow? Or just general comparisons on the line by line?

 

Thanx for judging!

[Taehyung 9]

Yeah i'll figure something out with the 2ac lol but i guess i'm chill with the 1nc..

Oops. If you'd like, I can kick out of the K.

CX answers will be up shortly.