Jump to content

Recommended Posts

File Name: Thursday File, 4/3/20104

File Submitter: binghamtondebate

File Submitted: 03 Apr 2014

File Category: Thursday Files

Resolution: Latin America

 



4/3/2014 Thursday File
Produced by: Joe Leeson-Schatz, Director of Debate at Binghamton University

File includes 3 full scenarios: Wages, Patent Reform, and NSA Reform. All claim to be coming up to a vote next week. File also includes generic uniqueness updates and immigration updates.

***WAGES DA***. 2
SHELLS & BLOCK OVs. 3
Short Shell 4
Long Shell 7
Short Shell Overview.. 11
Long Shell Overview.. 14
UNIQUENESS. 17
Will Pass Now.. 18
Pushing Now.. 21
Top of Docket. 25
INTERNALS. 26
PC Key to Wage Increase. 27
ANSWERS TO.. 28
AT: Thumpers. 29
AT: GOP Will Block. 30
AT: Will Kill Jobs. 31
AT: Econ Collapse Doesn’t Cause War. 32
AT: No Brink to Econ Collapse. 34
IMPACT SCENARIOS. 36
Impacts - Economy. 37
Impacts - Sexism.. 39
AFF ANSWERS. 40
Non-Unique - Won’t Pass Now.. 41
Non-Unique - No Chance for Compromise. 42
No Impact - States Solve. 43
Impact Turn - Hurts Economy. 44
***PATENT REFORM DA***. 46
SHELLS & BLOCK OVs. 47
Short Shell 48
Long Shell 51
Universal Overview.. 55
UNIQUENESS. 56
April 8th Timeframe. 57
Passing. 58
AT: Delay On Vote. 60
INTERNALS. 61
PC Key. 62
Obama Pushing. 63
ANSWERS TO.. 65
AT: Reform Doesn’t Solve. 66
AT: Reform Doesn’t Solve (Fee Shifting). 68
AT: Squo Solves. 69
AT: Courts Solve. 70
AT: XO Solves. 72
IMPACT SCENARIOS. 74
Economic Competitiveness. 75
Green Tech. 77
Nanotech. 81
Nanotech (Health). 87
Pharmaceuticals. 90
AFF ANSWERS. 91
Won’t Pass. 92
Patent Reform Kills Economy. 94
No Impact. 96
***NSA DA***. 98
SHELL. 99
Universal Shell 100
UNIQUENESS. 102
Will Pass Now.. 103
Obama Pushing Now.. 104
Vote Coming Next Week. 106
ANSWERS TO.. 107
AT: NSA Power Solves Terrorism.. 108
AT: Congressional Action Not Needed. 109
AT: NSA Good. 110
IMPACTS. 111
Civil Liberties. 112
EU Alliance. 114
Environment. 117
UN Credibility. 120
AFF ANSWERS. 121
NSA Regulations Don’t Solve. 122
Impact Turn - Trojan Horse. 124
Impact Turn - Hurts Internet Freedom.. 126
Impact Turn - Terrorism.. 127
***GENERIC POLITICS***. 130
IMMIGRATION UPDATES. 131
Still On Table. 132
Will Pass Now.. 133
Is Dead. 134
No Impact. 135
NEGATIVE. 136
Obama Popularity On Rise. 137
AT: Obama PC On Venezuela Now.. 138
AFFIRMATIVE. 139
No PC Now.. 140
Obama Spending PC On Latin America Now.. 142
LINKS & LINK TURNS. 143
Engagement Popular. 144

 



Click here to download this file

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just wondering, what is the story behind the NSA DA & Patent Reform DA?

Venturing a guess..

 

NSA reform will pass, Obama pushing, PC key, plan kills PC, NSA reform key to <impact>

 

Patent Troll reform legislation will pass, Obama pushing, PC key, plan kills PC, Patent Troll reform key to <impact>

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

NSA scenario's impact is a police state in the 1NC shell. Additional impacts civil liberties, environmental regulations, and EU alliance.

 

Terminal impact to patent reform is economic competiveness in the shell. Lots of additional impacts as well.

 

Both scenarios are will pass, plan kills PC that's needed to make it pass, impact. The wage dis/ad has a focus link in the long shell as well as a PC link, which means even if plan is popular / increases PC that plan still triggers the d/a since it distracts Obama from being able to push the legislation. Wages has an econ impact scenario in the shell and a moral obligation impact that comes out in the overview.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...