Jump to content
The-Troll

Conditionality

Recommended Posts

File Name: Conditionality

File Submitter: The-Troll

File Submitted: 21 Jul 2013

File Category: Theory

Resolution: Latin America

 



Table of Contents
***Aff Theory Core***......................................................................................................................................... 3
Strat Sheet..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
Condo Short 2AC....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 6
1AR Overview Short.............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 7
1AR Overview Long................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 8
Strat Skew EXT........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Interp EXT.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
Reject the Team EXT............................................................................................................................................................................................................ 11
AT: Counter Interp We get # of arguments.......................................................................................................................................................... 12
***Impact Debate***........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 13
Going for Education............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 14
***Answers***....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
AT: Rational Decision-making...................................................................................................................................................................................... 16
AT: Neg Flex............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 17
AT: Condo Inevitable.......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
AT: Time Skew Inevitable................................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
AT: Aff Time Bias................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 20
AT: Negation Theory........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
AT: Perms Check Abuse.................................................................................................................................................................................................... 22
AT: Perms are Worse.......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 23
AT: 2AR Always Has Options........................................................................................................................................................................................ 24
AT: Dispo Worse.................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 25
AT: 2AC Should be Hard.................................................................................................................................................................................................... 26
AT: Best Policy Option....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 27
AT: Real World Policy........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 28
AT: Plan Focus of Debate.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 29
AT: 2NR Checks Abuse....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
AT: Cheap Shot........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 31
AT: Add-ons Solve Offense.............................................................................................................................................................................................. 32
AT: Depth Over Breadth................................................................................................................................................................................................... 33
AT: Performative Contradiction Good.................................................................................................................................................................... 34
AT: Reasonability Checks Back Abuse.................................................................................................................................................................... 35
AT: We’re a Small School................................................................................................................................................................................................... 36
AT: 1AC is 8-Minute Defense Against Squo........................................................................................................................................................... 37
AT: We Defend Our Worldview.................................................................................................................................................................................... 38
AT: Clash Checks Abuse.................................................................................................................................................................................................... 39
AT: Condo Increases Education................................................................................................................................................................................... 40
***Condo=Huge In the Round***............................................................................................................................................................................... 41
Potential Abuse is a Voting Issue................................................................................................................................................................................ 42
Theory Outweighs K Framework.............................................................................................................................................................................. 43
Condo outweighs Ontology/Being............................................................................................................................................................................. 44
Theory Outweighs Topicality....................................................................................................................................................................................... 45
Condo Outweighs ASPEC.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 46
Condo Outweighs Framework..................................................................................................................................................................................... 47
***2AR***.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 48
Old 2AR Overview................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 49
Large 2AR Overview........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 50
2AR Block if they have no Counter-Interp........................................................................................................................................................... 51
Err Aff............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 53
Condo Cards.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 54
***Theory Core-Negative***............................................................................................................................. 58
2NC Condo Good.................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 59
Long Condo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 60
2NR Condo Good.................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 61
2NR They-Go-For-It Condo Bad................................................................................................................................................................................. 62
2NC Dispo Good...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 63
Severance Perms Bad 2NC Short................................................................................................................................................................................. 64
Severance Perms Bad 2NR Short................................................................................................................................................................................. 65
Severance Perms Bad 2NR Long.................................................................................................................................................................................. 66
Multiple Perms Bad.............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 67
Timeframe Perms Bad........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 68
Intrinsic Perms Bad............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 69
Pics Good 2NC.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 70
Pics Good 2NR Normal....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 71
Pics Good 2NR Long............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 72
Agent Counterplans Good................................................................................................................................................................................................ 73
Consult Counterplans Good........................................................................................................................................................................................... 74
Multiple Plank Counterplans Good............................................................................................................................................................................ 75
Functional Competition Good....................................................................................................................................................................................... 76
Conditions Counterplans Good.................................................................................................................................................................................... 77
Politics Good............................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 79
AT: DA Not Intrinsic............................................................................................................................................................................................................ 80
International Fiat Good with Kick-Out CPs......................................................................................................................................................... 81

 



Click here to download this file

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

4 year debater. won national tournaments 

Your name, the school you debated for, and the national tournaments you won would be important things to share. People are much more likely to trust a file from an actual person as opposed to a user on a forum. 

  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
looks more like that Going for Education

 

We isolated 2 unique internal links to education out of the 2AC that are both specific

 

1. If they kick their arguments then we never get to debate it out—this means that there is a bunch of undeveloped things out of the 1NC that we never get to learn about. Instead, we just try and get through the 2AC only to have you kick it. In a world where we cannot learn about different counterplans and k’s, we lose the whole aspect of Negative debate.

 

2. Conditionality means they can just read a text or shell and then drop it. It justifies them not researching their off case positions and instead putting bad ones they know they will kick in the 1NC.  This decreases out education because they don’t research specific planks which means that no one will spend time actually researching.

 

3. Education is the biggest impact on the flow—if we prove that we lose education through either or both of our internal links we get the impact. Education is in essence why we do debate and if we lose it then there is no point of debate.

 

4. Education leads to a loss of clash in the round—if we have no clash then debate should no longer be called debate and will turn into a sport where we increasingly try to beat the Neg to no avail while they run conditional arguments.

 

5. We lose topic specific education because as teams run more and more bad conditional arguments, we’ll have to start reading weird advantages and increasingly bad parts of the topic.

 

6. Education outweighs fairness—multiple reasons:

            A. Education is the basis of all fairness because if we don’t get the arguments and have the           background and in-round education, then we will not have fair debates.

            B. Their fairness claims are bad—leads to judge intervention because the definition of whether something is fair or not is arbitrary. Education is not because if we understand and get education on a       fully developed argument, then it is fair.

            C. There is no impact to a loss of fairness—the impact to loss of education is what we highlight—it’s a horrible debate season and no clash.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Education is in essence why we do debate"

 

Does anyone actually debate because they want to learn something? I just assumed people debated for the sake of argumentation and education was this cool side effect...

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly I dont get it. why would anyone want 55 pages of condo bad. Obviously this wont be your A-strat and if what the-troll posted was his 2AC shell why would you waste that much time on it. One can only win on it when the other team completely drops it. Spending $10 on a file wont make them more likely to drop it.

Hey, be carful now. The-Troll doesn't take kindly to opinions. If you're not careful, you'll get a neg rep.

 

By the way, I don't agree with your analysis on condo. It's totally possible to win even if the other team responds. That's why you have to debate warrants.

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

We isolated 2 unique internal links to education out of the 2AC that are both specific

 

1. If they kick their arguments then we never get to debate it out—this means that there is a bunch of undeveloped things out of the 1NC that we never get to learn about. Instead, we just try and get through the 2AC only to have you kick it. In a world where we cannot learn about different counterplans and k’s, we lose the whole aspect of Negative debate.

 

2. Conditionality means they can just read a text or shell and then drop it. It justifies them not researching their off case positions and instead putting bad ones they know they will kick in the 1NC.  This decreases out education because they don’t research specific planks which means that no one will spend time actually researching.

 

This is actually terrible.

 

1. impact inevitable

a. i could read a bunch of DAs and kick them - and off flies the education into space forever 

b. 2NR choice solves - like come on (A counterinterp as stupid as - as many condo as you want but cant kick it till the 2NR - solves all your offense)

 

2. This is literally the worst argument ever

a. the negative would lose the fucking debate if they didnt have coherent evidence - you shouldn't be complaining if this is happening

b. this is also inevitable - i could read 13 DAs and kick every single one of them - same skew and isnt condo

 

Not only do you not have an interp you dont provide a real internal link and all of your impact are inevitable in a world with absolutely no condo - I hope nobody actually buys this files - you're better off with out it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...