Jump to content
Hong Kong Phooey

Michigan Tournament of Champions and Junior Varsity State Finals

Recommended Posts

PLEASE EMAIL michiganpolicydebate@gmail.com SOON SO INTEREST CAN BE GAUGED

Michigan Policy Debate Association Offers

The Michigan Tournament of Champions and JV States

Sponsored by MSCI (Michigan Speech Coaches Incorporated)

and DUDE (Detroit Urban Debate Education)

January 29-30, 2010

The DUDE and MSCI are working with the MPDA to create an opportunity for your students. On January 29-30, 2010 at Dexter High School, these three organizations will be offering a Tournament of Champions and a JV State Tournament. All profits will benefit the Urban Debate League (see below).


Varsity Tournament of Champions:

Teams (an individual debater and his/her specific partner) will be awarded one bid for every Michigan Invitational tournament at which they break. In the special circumstance that a tournament allows more than half the field to break, bids will only be awarded to teams participating in the first break round that contains half, or less than half, of the field.


Teams will qualify for the tournament when they have accumulated 2 (two) bids. Bids are tied to a specific two debaters, thus a debater who has 1 (one) bid with Partner X and 1 bid with Partner Y will not qualify, but can appeal to MPDA for an at large bid (which may or may not be awarded).At large bids are limited to one per school. The circumstances under which a team will be awarded an at large bid are:



  1. The above scenario where a debater has a bid with multiple partners, but not two bids with any one partner.

  2. If a school, as a whole, qualifies zero or one team(s), then they will be given an at large bid for one team/a second team of their choice. Schools may select any 2-person team to send, regardless of number of bids accumulated. We encourage, but under no circumstances require, that schools send a team of two debaters in their senior year as their at large team. Keep in mind that at large bids are limited to one per school.

  3. Teams may send an e-mail to michiganpolicydebate@gmail.com to appeal for an at large bid because of special circumstances. (For example: a team that was 4-0 at a tournament and certain to break and receive their second bid, but had to drop out of the tournament because of a family emergency or medical reason, would almost certainly receive an at large bid)


All-State System (Who is named All-State?)

At the Michigan Varsity Tournament of Champions, we will be awarding debaters with honorary positions on the first and second team all-state. The six individual debaters accumulating the highest number of MPDA points will be awarded to the first team all-state. The six individual debaters accumulating the next highest number of MPDA points will be awarded to the second team all-state. In the event of a tie, difficulty of tournament schedule and other factors will be used to pick the winner. Students on the losing side of the tie, and thus not awarded to first or second team all-state, will be given honorary mentions at the award ceremony. Points will be awarded as follows: (only varsity/open division will apply)


Tournament Attendance:

0-4 Michigan Invitationals Attended____________1 Point

5-8 Michigan Invitationals Attended____________3 Points

9+ Michigan Invitationals Attended____________5 Points


Speaker Awards:

5th Place Speaker ___________________________1 Point

4th Place Speaker ___________________________2 Points

3rd Place Speaker ___________________________3 Points

2nd Place Speaker ___________________________4 Points

1st Place Speaker____________________________5 Points


Speaker award points are cumulative; each additional speaker award adds to the total number of points earned.


Break Rounds:

Each Break Round that a person debates in is worth 2 points. If a debater is in two break rounds at a tournament, he/she has added 4 points to his/her total. An additional 3 points is awarded to the two debaters who win the finals round.


Win Percentage:

0-10%_____________________________________0 Points

10-20%____________________________________1 Point

20-30%____________________________________2 Points

30-40%____________________________________3 Points

40-50%_____________________________________4 Points

50-60%_____________________________________6 Points

60-70%_____________________________________8 Points

70-80%_____________________________________11 Points

80-90%_____________________________________14 Points

90-100%____________________________________18 Points


JV State Tournament

Each school can send up to 4 teams and each debater must be in their first two years of high school debate. No other requirements apply.


The JV division will have 5 rounds: 3 rounds on Friday, 2 preliminary rounds on Saturday and will break to an appropriate number of elimination rounds.



Entry fee is $60 dollars a varsity team, $50 dollars a JV team. Checks should be written to Detroit Urban Debate Education. Profits from this tournament will benefit the Urban Debate League, offering scholarships to summer camps and to reduce membership fees for UDL teams to join the MIFA.



Each team must provide a judge for 3 prelims and all are obligated for the first out-round. Some judges will be available for hire for $50.



The Michigan Speech Coaches, Inc. has generously donated money to purchase speaker awards and team awards for both the JV States and the MI TOC.


JV Entry:

Please email your entry to Michiganpolicydebate@gmail.com along with the judges accounting for the obligation, if you need a hired judge just note in the e-mail.


Qualified Varsity:

If the team has qualified send an e-mail entering to michiganpolicydebate@gmail.com with the list of the two tournaments that qualified them and how far they advanced.


At-Large Varsity:

If you have not qualified a team and you are choosing to you use the automatic at large option, send the name of the team.


If you have qualified a team and want to apply for an at large, send the name of the team with records for their top 5 tournaments. If the partners did not debate with each other for 5 tournaments send a list of all the tournaments they did debate with each other and a list of each individual’s top 5 tournaments (include records and any speaker awards for all of the above).



Send an e-mail to michiganpolicydebate@gmail.com with a list of each applicants attended tournaments as well as record and speaker awards in the top 5.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I got this in an email from Alan yesterday:


§ Registration at 2:30.

§ Pairings out at 3:15. Release both pairings at once.

§ The rounds on Friday start at 3:30

§ Round 2 at 5:30.

§ Round 3 starts at 8:00.

o Day 2

§ Breakfast and pairings at 8 AM.

§ Round 4 starts at 8:30 AM.

§ Round 5 at 11:00 AM.

§ Lunch at 12:30

§ Quarters/ Round 6 at 2:00 PM.

§ Awards at 4:00 PM.

§ Semis (JV) at 5:00 PM.

§ Finals (JV) at 8:00 PM.


I don't have a team list, hopefully he'll post one here.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

to my knowledge



1) Bro-Rice 16 ballots

2) Dexter 14 ballots

3) Cadilac 4 Ballots

4) Tcc 2 Ballots



1) Lukas Hosford

2) Evan Hebert Bro Rice

3) Michael Crowe Bro Rice




1) Dow W? d. 8) Dexter BP

3) Dexter MC d. 6) Tcc ??

?) Tcc Q? d. ?) Dow ??

?) Tcc S? over Tcc F?



1) Dow W? d. ?) Tcc S?

3) Dexter MC d. ?) Tcc Q? 2-1 mendenhall, cronin, zagorin*



1) Dow W? d. 3) Dexter MC 3-0 Cronin, Deming, Quist


Speaks that i know

1) Kevin Query Tcc

6) Brandon Canniff Dexter

7) David Paolella Dexter

9) Katie Stanton Tcc


All State team

Matt Kaas

Flora Zhang

Evan Hebert

Luke Hosford (Captain)

+ 2 more

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Couple of additions to Luke's results:

Semis: Dow WB d. TCC SC 3-0

Deming, Reed, *Skeean


Complete speakers:

1 - Kevin Query, TCC

2 - Grace Davis, Dow

3 - Chyanne Hacket, Dow

4 - Sarah Walker, Lifeskills

5 - Roman Motely, Northwestern

6 - Brandon Caniff, Dexter

7 - David Paoella, Dexter

8 - Gracie Fitzsimmons, TCC

9 - Katie Stanton, TCC

10 - Alesia Dunlap, Groves

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
what happened to the rest of the teams in the varsity division?

Haha, that was all the teams.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

it was a double round robin, every team hit every other team on the aff and neg, 6 rounds, three judges per round, 18 potential ballots per team

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...