Jump to content
DB8T

Documentary on HS Debate - HBO June 16

Recommended Posts

From the HBO website:

 

2007 LOS ANGELES FILM FESTIVAL - AUDIENCE AWARD WINNER **

 

Through the stories of two debate teams, the fascinating intricacies of high school debate give way to a portrait of the equally complex racial and class divide in American education in Resolved. As Matt and Sam, gifted debaters from an affluent Texas suburb, rise to the semifinals in their bid to win the national Tournament of Champions, Richard and Louis, talented inner-city debaters from Long Beach, CA, mount a successful challenge to modern debate by refocusing on personal experience and dialogue in their own quest for the championship. This 90-minute film offers a verité, behind-the-scenes look at the stresses and pressures of this highly competitive pursuit, while serving as a primer on the idiosyncratic techniques that have evolved over the years in high-school policy debate. Inspiring and enlightening, Resolved reveals a constantly shifting sport that is as much philosophy as it is a competition.

 

The primary players in the film are four debaters who are equally talented, yet from very different backgrounds. From well-to-do Highland Park, Texas we meet Matt, who rises to the top of the team despite his sophomore status, and Sam, who is one of the best high-school debaters in the country, but otherwise shirks his academic responsibilities. From the racially diverse Long Beach High School, we meet Richard, who decided to take up debate to stay out of trouble and "keep his head straight," and Louis, who one of his coaches says is the smartest high school kid he's ever met. We are also introduced to coaches, judges, and debaters on other teams who populate the high-school debate circuit.

 

In addition, Resolved features appearances by several well-known former debaters including: broadcaster Jane Pauley, actor Josh Lucas, former White House aid Karl Rove, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, and journalist Juan Williams, who each offer their insights on how their participation in debate has shaped their lives, and how debate has proved to be an invaluable foundation in their careers.

 

Resolved utilizes clever animated segments to illustrate the mechanics of debate. Before "the spread," or speed speaking, was introduced in the 1960s, debate was primarily characterized by eloquence and persuasion. Since, debate has emphasized information and academic research, with persuasiveness taking a back seat. Debaters began using a densely-worded jargon that few people could understand, and crowds dwindled. Where once high school debates filled auditoriums, they now take place in small rooms, sparsely populated by the few people who can understand what is being said and the even fewer people who have the ability to participate.

 

CREDITS: Produced and Directed by Greg Whiteley; Executive Produced by Lisa Vick Kraus, Peter Kraus, Mark Clark, Sarah J. Clark, Mark and Wendy Stanley, Andy and Liz Waters; Edited by Greg Whiteley, Tom Runquist and Brad Barber; Director of Photography: Tristan Whitman and Liam Dalzell. For HBO: Senior Producer: Nancy Abraham; Executive Producer: Sheila Nevins.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let me tell you what. I did not care for resolved. I felt as if the filmmakers were incredible biased. They took a deep in depth look at the trials and tribulations of Long Beach Jordan HS in Los Angeles. This school does their own version of the Louisville Project coupled with philosophical teachings of a South American philosopher. From what I saw as well as from the comments I heard from the "straight up" debaters they interviewed, like those from Damien High School, the filmmakers specifically edited and manipulated what people said to portray white debaters as "elitist" and "racist", which, coincidentally, are two of the main arguments from Long Beach Jordan. I was very disappointed in the neutrality of the movie, as well as how their focus on Long Beach...distracted the viewer away from actual debate...ironic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I disagree with courtney, it was very cool to see and very watchable.

I think Courtney is upset because it an attack on her style of debate.

 

you end up rooting for both the underdog and the top dog, what else would you want.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Courtney, they spent just as much time on the team from Texas as the team from Long Beach. And the team from Texas was an elite version of what is seen by some as "real debate" these days. I didn't see the directors putting down or disapproving of what Sam and Matt did.

 

Furthermore, I liked how they balanced some of what Long Beach Jordan was doing by having the final judge comment about the inherent contradictions in some of what they said. In their final round of the film, the other team pointed out the problem with seemingly labeling everything said by SQ debaters as "racist."

 

So you had one team trying to perfect the accepted style and one team trying to rebel against it. That seems pretty balanced.

 

I really liked the little cartoon parts. I know I could have used little animated sequences to explain the basics of various rounds of debate!:) I also think it did a good job of providing some historical perspective that connected what was in Resolved to what was in other debate films, like the Great Debaters. They put it right up front that debate has changed and evolved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If anything, you should watch it to see the smart young lady giving her RFD to Long Beach at Berkeley 2 years ago. (Come on, it's my 2 seconds of fame...)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, I saw that and noticed your name scroll across the bottom of the screen. What a thrill!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...