Jump to content
ihsdebate

550pg PMF file!!

Recommended Posts

made by our very own movingonup!! mega props to him on such a sweet ass file; from waht i've read its pretty bad ass man.

 

discuss.

 

*let it be known that this is the only thread in this forum for useless banter, so take advantage of it...there are absolutley no ruls in here, its like the texas of the national service forum....anything goes and everythings bigger (hence the 500pg file)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is this the same thing as PMC (private military contractors)?

 

If so, a 550 pg. file is impressive... is it on/going to be on evazon?

 

Basically, the plan calls for the USFG to hire a bunch of mercenaries.

 

If it is the same thing, advantages I have seen are:

 

War on Terror

Iran and NK

Heg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If so, a 550 pg. file is impressive... is it on/going to be on evazon?

 

No, WFI Put it out.

Basically, the plan calls for the USFG to hire a bunch of mercenaries.

 

Hell no. PMCs are bad. We do NOT hire them. The plan is to have a draft (or whatever form of enlistment that will get you about 50,000 persons) so the military can offset the need to hire PMCs.

 

sounds badass

Oh, it is

 

What advantages/plan text?

 

Iraq reconstruction

Weapons proliferation

Militarism

CMR

Military Readiness

Human Rights

International Law

Drugs in Columbia

North Korea

Afghanistan

War on Drugs (good and bad)

Terrorism

Democracy (could also be a SOP)

Sex Trafficking

Government Legitimacy

Military Backlash

Sovereignty

Imperialism

Un Credibility

MNCs (Multinational Corporations)

 

The camp I lab led at put that out too, but it wasn't that great of an aff.

 

This one rocks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey I just got this Aff and its totally sweet. I really like the adv's, cuz they aren't ridiculously unbelievable and they can function as disads against some other Affs. Plus a huge neg file to go with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got the WFI camp and this wasn't in it. Could someone help me? Is there more than on wave, or camp, or something else. I really want this file but it isn't there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I got the WFI camp and this wasn't in it. Could someone help me? Is there more than on wave, or camp, or something else. I really want this file but it isn't there.

 

Should have been the policy 1st week aff files.

 

"Sovereignty"

 

Explain?

 

PMFs undermine national sovereignty because they cause the government to lose control of its military action. The state maintaining a monopoly on violence is critical to sovereignty. The evidence is pretty sweet. Can internal link to human rights and/or rule of law

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Iraq reconstruction

Weapons proliferation

Militarism

CMR

Military Readiness

Human Rights

International Law

Drugs in Columbia

North Korea

Afghanistan

War on Drugs (good and bad)

Terrorism

Democracy (could also be a SOP)

Sex Trafficking

Government Legitimacy

Military Backlash

Sovereignty

Imperialism

Un Credibility

MNCs (Multinational Corporations)

 

*yawn*

it's still a draft aff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The files I got are:

Framework starter

Coast Guard Neg

Kato

Draft Update

Topicality

Coercion Practice set

Truncated Politics Links file

Schopenauer

Levinas State Good Args

Hegemony Practice Set

Consult Canada CP

NGO CP cards

A2 Exitentialism

Pre-Camp Politics

Short Hegemony Bad DA

Corps Neg

Anarchy final

Draft Neg Tourney

Nuclear Malthus Short

States CP final

Politics links final

Volunteerism tradeoff- tournament set

The Hulk

Human Rights K

Coercion

Volunteerism Tradeoff

Midterms Da

Prolif Good final

Creamy Agambisque

Draft Aff

Completed PTX Scenarios and Internals

WFI pre-camp set

PTX impacts

Normativity K final

Preemption DA

Draft aff tourney

Leadership final

Malthus answers short

Fiscal Discipline DA final

Heg Good/Bad Big

Biopolitics K final

Americorps Aff/Neg final

Exitentialism

XO Supplement

Women in Combat Aff/Neg final

Force Expansion Aff/Neg final

XO CP final

Developement and Labor movements

Chronopolitics

God is Good

CMR Supplemental

Theory Death WFI

Malthus - Rights and Nuclear

Threat Construction K final

 

Is the PMC aff the only thing I am missing? Or is there more that the camp put out that I don't have? someone please let me know.

 

Thanx,

Stephen

 

PS.

The titles are the same as they are written in the .zip file I have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it's still a draft aff.
It isn't a topical plan, in my opinion, but it isn't a draft...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

look at movingonup's synopsis of this plan text...

PMCs are bad. We do NOT hire them. The plan is to have a draft (or whatever form of enlistment that will get you about 50,000 persons) so the military can offset the need to hire PMCs.

it's a draft.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it's a draft.
My bad. Having a flashback to the UN topic, I guess... :o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I would beat this aff by straight turning this.

 

Damn, you must be incredible to be able to make a few 1NC arguments that will win you the roung regardless of the skill of the other team and the arguments they make in response to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...