73 files
-
Carbon Tax CP - Price Cut**
This file is an advantage CP to solve global warming advantages and any affs that claim to bolster the renewable energy market. I cut this originally for the college energy topic (undefeated when we went for it) and have updated it with 2014 evidence.
Given that global warming is almost certain to be one of the biggest advantages on next year’s Oceans topic, this file is a must-have. The solvency cards are fantastic, seriously a silver-bullet against any warming adv’s. Included are a variety of versions of the CP that have never been read (to account for potential DA’s/to bolster politics shields) and extensive 2NC blocks to answer every possible arg you will hear in response.
In terms of the net benefit, you can go for any DA specific to oceans exploration/development. Additionally, the politics shields are very solid.
FYI section includes a general overview of how a carbon tax would be implemented.
232 downloads
0 comments
Updated
-
Russia Relations Adv CP
This was an advantage CP written to solve the Russia Relations adv for the Bering Strait aff/also some add-ons and internal links to other advs. I am not posting the entirety of the index because it has not been read yet and I would like for the buyer(s) to be able to maintain the element of surprise. Politics is an excellent net benefit along with any other DA's you have based off the tunnel. Please message me if you have any questions.
1NC CP. 2
2NC Overview.. 4
Avoids Politics. 9
Solves Relations. 11
Solves Accidents/War. 13
AT: ------------ 15
AT: -----------. 16
AT: ------------ 19
He is an assistant coach at the University of North Texas and has coached multiple college teams to late out-rounds of many national tournaments including Wake Forest (Octos), UT-Dallas (Finals), UNT (Finals), UMKC (Octos), Wichita State (First place). This season UNT has had two top 25 ranked teams. He has also been coaching high school debate for over 3 years. His students have been in elimination rounds of dozens of national tournaments, including semi-finals of the TOC and NDCA. He has worked at numerous debate camps and judged elimination of national tournaments, including finals of the TOC. He debated four years at Deer Park High School and four years and the University of Texas at Dallas where his accomplishments included: three time qualifier to the NDT, first-round bid to the NDT, octo-finals of the NDT, 1st place at the UMKC tournament, octo-finals of GSU, octos at Harvard (twice), semis of Georgia, semis of Emporia, Kentucky Rd Robin invite, Pittsburgh Rd Robin Invite, 1st place at the Arizona Debate Institute Fellows Tournament and numerous speaker awards.
He debated four years at Deer Park High School and four years and the University of Texas at Dallas where his accomplishments included: three time qualifier to the NDT, first-round bid to the NDT, octo-finals of the NDT, 1st place at the UMKC tournament, octo-finals of GSU, octos at Harvard (twice), semis of Georgia, semis of Emporia, Kentucky Rd Robin invite, Pittsburgh Rd Robin Invite, 1st place at the Arizona Debate Institute Fellows Tournament and numerous speaker awards.
3 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Advantage Counterplans File
By jakeswede
A file filled with counterplans specifically meant to capture the affirmative's advantages. Has 45 counterplans that all function separately from each other.
Table of Contents
Warming CP’s 13
Ocean Fertilization 14
1NC Ocean Fertilization CP 15
Ocean Fertilization CP – Solvency 17
Ocean Fertilization CP – Politics NB 19
Ocean Fertilization CP – Politics NB – CEOs 20
Ocean Fertilization CP – Spending NB 21
Ocean Fertilization CP – AT: U.N. Regulations 24
Aff Answers 28
Geo-Engineering fails – large technical and scientific uncertainties and doesn’t eliminate the need to reduce GHGs. 29
Geoengineering replicates the failures of the Manhattan Project – leads to long-term environmental damage 30
***MP = Manhattan Project 31
G-E fails – no sustainable international cooperation, and conflict prevents solvency 32
Emissions mitigation is comparatively better 33
Cuts are comparatively more effective and predictable – any GE strategy risks global climate disruption 34
Geoengineering will be perceived as a clandestine weapon – leads to war 35
Leads to conflict 36
Destroys the Environment 37
Unpopular 38
Peridotite 39
1NC Peridotite CP 40
Peridotite CP – Spending NB 41
Solar Radiation Management 43
1NC Solar Radiation Management CP 44
SRM CP – Spending NB 46
Trees 48
1NC Trees CP 49
Trees CP – Solvency 50
Trees CP – Spending NB 51
Artificial Trees CP 53
1NC 54
Iron Dumping CP 56
1NC 57
2NC/1NR Solvency 58
Carbon Tax CP 61
Carbon Tax CP 1NC 62
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 63
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 66
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 67
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 70
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 73
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 74
Solvency – Emissions/Warming 77
Solvency – Dependence 78
Elections NB – A2: Unpopular 79
Elections NB – A2: Popular 81
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 82
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 85
Carbon Tax – Aff Answers 86
Solvency 87
Solvency – Turns Econ 88
A2: Carbon Tax K Warming 89
Links to Elections – Unpopular 90
Links to Agenda Politics – Unpopular 91
Ocean Thermal Energy Conservation tech CP 93
OTEC CP 1NC 94
Ext – Solves Warming 95
Ext – Solves Competitiveness 96
Alt Energy Popular 97
Alt Energy Unpopular 98
OTEC – No Link (Politics) 99
AT: OTEC Bad 100
OTEC – Aff Answers 101
Solvency 102
Microalgae CP 105
1NC Shell 106
Solvency Wall 107
At: Cost 110
Cellulosic Ethanol CP 111
1NC Shell 112
Solvency Wall 113
Vs. HSR 115
***Aff answers:*** 116
Clean Tech 117
1NC Shell 118
2nc – solvency wall 120
2nc – competitiveness 122
R&D solves 124
NIE solves 125
A2 DoE key 127
Ptx / elections NB 128
Aff – No Solve Competitiveness 129
Economy/Competitiveness CP’s 130
Corporate Tax Reform 133
1NC 134
2NC Solvency 137
Elections – CP Popular 140
AT: Hurts revenue 141
AT: Doesn’t Solve Competitiveness 143
*AFF – Isolated Corporate Tax Reform Fails 144
*AFF – Doesn’t Solve Keynes 145
H1B Visas (Neg) 147
H1B CP 1NC 148
H1B CP 1NC 150
2NC Solvency – Economy 151
2NC Solvency – Economy 153
2NC Solvency – Economy 156
2NC Solvency – Economy 158
2NC Solvency – Economy 160
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 162
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 164
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 166
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 168
Solv – Hegemony 169
Solv – Hegemony 172
Solv – Green Tech 174
Solv – Hegemony 177
Solv – STEM Shortage XT 178
Solv – Boomer Retirement XT 180
Solv – Outsourcing XT 181
A2: Cap not Filled 182
A2: Wages 183
A2: Brain Drain 184
A2: Brain Drain 186
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 187
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 190
H1B – Aff Answers 192
Solvency 193
Solvency 195
A2: Skills Shortage 197
A2: Labor Shortage 198
Wages DA 200
Links to Agenda Politics 201
EB Visas CP 1NC 203
2NC Solvency – General 206
2NC Solvency – Economy 208
2NC Solvency – Economy 213
2NC Econ Other 216
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 218
2NC Solvency – Competitiveness 221
Solv – Economic Leadership 222
Solv – Hegemony 223
Solv- Green Tech 226
Solv – STEM Shortage XT 229
Solv – Boomer Retirement XT 231
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 233
Cuban Embargo CP 239
2NC Embargo Bad General 242
2NC Econ Extensions 244
2NC Soft Power DA 246
2NC Heg Generals 250
2NC Prolif internal 252
2NC Environmental Leadership DA 253
2NC Deforestation Add-on 255
2NC Popular 257
2NC Ableism internals 262
2NC Will say Yes 264
2NC Agriculture internal link 266
2NC grain internal 268
2NC Rice internal 270
2NC Dairy Internal 272
2NC renewable energy internal link 273
2NC Ethanol internal 275
2NC illegal immigration internal 277
2NC spending internal 278
2NC Oil Spill Add on 279
2NC Oil Dependence 281
2NC Oil/Venezuela internal 283
2NC European Allies 285
2NC Russia Relations Internals 286
2NC Russia/Venezuela/Brazil/China internals 288
2NC International Law Internal 289
2NC drugs, terror, trafficking 290
2NC Terrorism 292
2NC Genocide 294
2NC Demo Promo 297
2NC Poverty Internal 301
2NC Internet access Internal 304
2NC UN/Int’l Law Legitimacy 305
2NC South America internal 306
2NC Imperialism 308
2NC Nickel/Cobalt internal 310
2NC hardpower defense 312
2NC realism 313
2NC solves communism 315
A2 Cuba heg counter 317
A2 Repeal helps Castro 319
A2 Cant solve right now 321
A2 aff solves CP general 323
A2 Perm (Prez only Plans) 325
Aff – Links to Politics 326
Restoring Americas Future CP 328
Note - What the CP does 329
Restoring America’s Future 1NC Shell 330
2NC Solvency - Econ 332
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 333
Penny/Nickel CP 335
1NC Shell 336
2NC Solvency 338
2NC Avoids Politics 339
Aff – Links to Politics 340
Sunshades CP 1nc 342
2NC Solvency – Generic 344
2NC Solvency – Plant Growth 346
2NC Solvency – Feasibility 348
2NC CO2 DA NB 350
Aff – Cant Solve Warming 352
Aff – Warming Turns 353
Heg CPs 355
1NC Seabasing CP 356
Solvency 2NC 357
Seabasing CP – AT: No Capability 366
Solv – Quick Response XT 367
Solv – A2: Asymmetric Threats 369
Solv – A2: No Capability 370
Solv – A2: Vulnerable 372
Solv – A2: Allied Cooperation 373
A2: Econ k Heg 374
A2: Power Projection Not Key 375
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 376
Sea Basing – Aff Answers 378
Solvency – Heg 379
Solvency – No Tech 381
Solvency – Allied Coop 384
Links to Agenda Politics 385
Shipbuilding 1NC Shell 387
2NC Solvency – Generic 388
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 390
Aff – Links to Ptx 391
Aff – Links to Elections 392
Oil CPs 395
Fuel Economy CP 396
1NC 397
2NC Solves Oil Dependence 399
Popular – Public 401
Solves better than HSR 403
Tech Possible 404
Solve Stimulus 405
Solve Warming 407
*Aff Answers 410
Building Codes (Neg) 412
Building Codes CP 1NC 413
Solvency – Dependence 414
Solvency – Dependence 417
Solvency – A2: No Oil In Buildings 419
Solvency – Economy/Warming 421
Solvency – Economy/Warming 424
Solvency – Economy/Warming 427
Solvency – Economy 429
Solvency – Warming 431
Solvency – Warming 433
A2: State Spending DA 435
FYI – How States Adopt Energy Codes 436
Building Codes – Aff Answers 438
Solvency 439
Solvency 442
State Spending DA – Link 444
Biofuels (Neg) 446
Biofuels CP 1NC 447
2NC Solvency – Dependence 449
2NC Solvency – Dependence 451
Solv – Environment 453
Solv – Economy 454
Incentives Solve 455
Incentives Solve 457
Agenda Politics NB – A2: Unpopular 459
Biofuels – Aff Answers 460
Solvency – Incentives Fail 461
Solvency – Dependence 465
Solvency – Warming 468
Links to Agenda Politics 470
Keystone XL CP 1NC 472
2NC Solves Dependence/Prices 473
Solves Econ/Oil 474
Avoids PTX - Agenda 476
Avoids PTX - Elections 478
A2 Pipeline = Emissions 479
A2 Leaks 480
Aff – Doesn’t solve jobs 481
Aff – Kills Jobs 482
Aff – Doesn’t Solve Oil 483
Aff – CP Hurts Econ 484
Aff – Kills Jobs 485
Aff – Doesn’t solve jobs 486
Aff – Links to PTX 487
Stimulus CPs 488
Tax Cuts CP 489
1NC 490
2NC Payroll Tax Solvency 492
2NC Unemployment Solvency 496
AT: Perm do Both 497
Tax Cuts Popular – Elections 499
Keynes Spending Fails 502
AT: Deficit 506
Ryan Tax Cuts 507
AT: Ryan Proposal Will Pass 509
Minimum Wage CP 512
1NC 513
AT: Minimum Wage Does Not Solve Stimulus 514
AT: Minimum Wage Not Popular with the Public 516
AT: Minimum Wage Kills Jobs 517
AT: Minimum Wages not Popular in Congress 518
Do Nothing CP 520
1NC 521
Do Nothing Solvency 523
Monetary Stimulus CP 526
1NC 527
Federal Employment Reserve Authority CP (Stimulus) 529
1NC 530
2NC Solvency 532
2NC Doesn’t Link to Politics 535
Terrorism Advantage CP 537
1NC 538
Solves Terror 541
---Immigration/Border Security 1NC 545
2NC Solvency - Generic 548
2NC CP Popular (politics net benefit) 551
---Intel Gathering 1NC 553
2NC Solvency - Generic 555
---NPT 1NC 558
2NC Solvency – Spill Over 560
2NC Prolif Bad– Stability 562
2NC Prolif Bad– Miscalc 564
Aff – NPT Fails 567
Aff – No Impact 570
Russia Coop 573
Note 574
1NC Shell 575
2NC Solvency - Relations 580
2NC Coop Good 581
2NC Coop Good - AIDs 583
2NC Coop Good - Sino-Russia War 585
China 588
China Cooperation CP 1NC– solves china relations, warming, terror 590
2NC Solvency - Cooperation 595
2NC Say Yes 597
2NC Relations Good 599
A2: High Now 601
Aff – Relations Resilient 602
Competition 606
Teaching Suggestion Motivation CP 607
More CP Solvency 608
CP Popular 610
Corporate Tax Credit 611
1NC Shell 612
2NC Solvency 614
CP Unpopular 621
Patent box 623
1NC Shell 624
Solvency Wall 626
Vs. Innovation 629
Aff – Links to Deficit DA 631
R&D tax credit 632
1NC Shell 633
Solvency Wall 635
2nc – jobs 639
Pollution 642
Fossil Fuels CP 643
1NC Shell 644
Solvency Wall 646
Economy NB 648
Helium 3 CP 649
1NC Shell 650
Air Pollution CP 653
1NC Shell 654
2NC Solvency – Generic 656
2NC Shields Elections NB 659
Aff – Links to Ptx 661
Air Control/Congestion CP 662
1NC Shell 663
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 664
2NC Solvency – Generic 665
2NC Solvency – Empirics 667
2NC Solvency – Congestion 668
2NC Solvency – Air Traffic 669
2NC Solvency – Cheap/Efficient 670
Aff – Links to Ptx 671
Biodiversity 675
Biodiversity CP 676
1NC Shell 677
2NC Solvency - Monitoring 678
2NC Solvency – Data 680
2NC Solvency – International Efforts 681
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 683
Aff - Links to Politics 685
Deforestation CPs 688
---Plank CP 689
1NC Shell 690
2NC Solvency – Warming 692
Incentivization 693
1NC Shell 694
2NC Solvency – Spills Over 695
2NC Solvency – Ag Competitiveness 696
2NC Solvency – Warming 700
2NC Solvency – National Security 702
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 703
Aff – No Solvency 704
Aff – No Implementation 705
Aff – US Action Fails - Drugs 706
Aff – US Action Fails - Profit 707
Natural Disasters 709
---FEMA CP 710
FEMA 1NC Shell 711
STATIM CP 713
1NC Shell 714
2NC Solvency – Generic 715
AmeriCorps 716
1NC Shell 717
2NC Solvency – Generic 718
2NC CP Popular (Politics NB) 720
Aff – Links to Ptx 722
566 downloads
Updated
-
"Government" PIC
By Green Tea
This counterplan is a word PIC out of the term 'government' in the plantext. The file comes complete with answers and extensions. While it may be a small file, it is effective and has not lost a single round yet.
“Government†PIC.................................................................................................................................................. 1
Long 1NC Shell........................................................................................................................................................ 2
Long 1NC Shell........................................................................................................................................................ 3
Long 1NC Shell........................................................................................................................................................ 4
Long 1NC Shell........................................................................................................................................................ 5
Short 1NC Shell....................................................................................................................................................... 7
Short 1NC Shell....................................................................................................................................................... 8
2NC – Overview...................................................................................................................................................... 9
2NC – Impact Calculus.......................................................................................................................................... 10
2NC – Solvency Magnifier.................................................................................................................................... 11
2NC – Short 1NC – Extra Solvency...................................................................................................................... 12
2NC – AT: Wrong Forum/In Round Solvency...................................................................................................... 13
2NC – Impact – Nuclear War................................................................................................................................ 14
2NC – Impact – Genocide/Value to Life................................................................................................................ 15
2NC – AT: Perm Do Both.................................................................................................................................... 16
2NC – AT: Perm Do CP....................................................................................................................................... 17
2NC – AT: Butler.................................................................................................................................................. 18
18 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Plasma Gasification CP
By Phantom707
This is a generic counterplan for the infrastructure topic based around plasma gasification. The way that the specific solvency evidence is phrased, you could also add in an objectivism/coercion/capitalism good kritik as a net benefit.
Plasma Gasification CP................................................................................... 1
1NC Shell.................................................................................................................................... 2
2NC Add Ons............................................................................................................................. 4
Answers To............................................................................................................................... 15
7 purchases
0 comments
Updated
-
Request Counterplan/"Demand" PIC
By Green Tea
This file is a PIC out of the word "Demand" in plantexts and replaces it with request. Many team with middle of the right/slightly left leaning affirmatives often make demands on the government in their plantext or advocacy statement. The counterplan instead makes a request saying that requests are a nonviolent form of communication and are a form of "giraffe" communication rather than "jackal" language that is violent. The counterplan comes with answers to every argument I have seen a team make against the counterplan and has beat teams on several topics. A good trick to have in your arsenal in case you are caught off guard by someone making a demand.
Request CP.. 1
CP 1NC. 2
U – Violent Communication Decreasing. 3
Solvency – Debate Round Key. 4
Solvency – Politics. 5
Impact – Demand Bad (Ethics). 7
Impact – Demands Bad. 8
Impact – Self-Fulfilling Prophecy. 9
Impact – Violence. 10
Impact – Herd Mentality. 12
2NC Overview.. 14
AT: Perm Do Both (1/2). 15
AT: Perm Do Both (2/3). 16
AT: Perm Do Both (3/3). 17
AT: Perm Do CP.. 18
AT: Jackal can’t be Escaped – Solves Politics. 19
AT: Requests Bad. 20
AT: Rosenburg= Pyschologist (Doesn’t Apply). 21
AT: Plan is Bipart Consensus. 22
AT: Request= Concessions/Reformist. 23
3 purchases
0 comments
Updated
-
"The" PIC
By X Spike
There's not much to say about this file. It's a very extensive "The" PIC file - 71 pages, including 2NC and 2NR blocks, more specific link work, impact work and more alt/CP solvency extensions. This is a file that I can say two things definitively about: 1) it has won a lot of debates, and 2) there isn't an argument to this CP that isn't answered by at least 2 cards in the file.
Index...................................................................................................................................... 1
1NC - “The†PIC.................................................................................................................. 3
1NC - “The†PIC.................................................................................................................. 4
2NC - Overview................................................................................................................... 6
2NR - Overview.................................................................................................................... 7
2NC - “Perm: do the CPâ€.................................................................................................. 8
2NC - “Perm: do bothâ€...................................................................................................... 9
2NC - “Perm: do bothâ€.................................................................................................... 10
2NC - Functional Competition........................................................................................ 11
2NC - (Word) PICs bad................................................................................................... 12
2NC - Censorship Bad.................................................................................................... 13
2NC - Censorship Bad.................................................................................................... 14
2NC - Discourse First..................................................................................................... 15
2NC - Discourse First..................................................................................................... 16
2NC - Discourse First..................................................................................................... 17
2NC - A2 “This is stupidâ€............................................................................................... 18
2NC - Grammar........................................................................................................... 19
2NC - Racism [MUST READ]........................................................................................... 20
2NC - Racism [MUST READ]........................................................................................... 21
2NC - Racism [MUST READ]........................................................................................... 22
2NC - Racism [MUST READ]........................................................................................... 23
2NR - Racism............................................................................................................... 24
2NC - Ethics Good......................................................................................................... 25
2NC - Ethics Good......................................................................................................... 26
2NC - Ethics Good......................................................................................................... 27
2NC - Ethics Good......................................................................................................... 28
2NR - Ethics Good......................................................................................................... 29
2NC - Freedom............................................................................................................. 30
2NR - Freedom............................................................................................................. 31
2NC - Util Bad.............................................................................................................. 32
2NC - Util Bad.............................................................................................................. 33
2NC - Util Bad.............................................................................................................. 34
2NR - Util Bad.............................................................................................................. 35
2NC - Realism.............................................................................................................. 36
2NR - Realism.............................................................................................................. 37
Link - Other................................................................................................................. 38
Link - Power/Knowledge................................................................................................ 39
Link - Bleiker/Acceptance.............................................................................................. 40
Link - Bleiker/Neutral Discourse..................................................................................... 41
Link - Campbell/Realism............................................................................................... 42
Link - Campbell/Objectivity.......................................................................................... 43
Link - Policy-making.................................................................................................... 44
Link - Peacekeeping...................................................................................................... 45
Link - Assumption........................................................................................................ 46
Link - Government Discourse......................................................................................... 47
Link - Naming.............................................................................................................. 48
Link - Naming/Nationalism........................................................................................... 49
Link - Failed States....................................................................................................... 50
Link - Development....................................................................................................... 51
Link - Humor............................................................................................................... 52
Impact - Tuathail......................................................................................................... 53
Impact - Tuathail......................................................................................................... 54
Impact - Biopower......................................................................................................... 55
Impact - Biopower......................................................................................................... 56
Impact - Rajaram 2NC Bomb......................................................................................... 57
Impact - Rajaram/Territoriality.................................................................................... 58
Impact - Rajaram/Territoriality.................................................................................... 59
Impact - Shapiro.......................................................................................................... 60
Impact - T/ War............................................................................................................ 61
Impact - Otherization................................................................................................... 62
Impact - Otherization................................................................................................... 63
Impact - Racism I/L...................................................................................................... 64
Impact - Racism I/L...................................................................................................... 65
Impact - Movements..................................................................................................... 66
Solvency - Language.................................................................................................... 67
Solvency - Re-thinking................................................................................................. 68
Solvency - Un-mapping................................................................................................ 69
Solvency - Tuathail...................................................................................................... 70
Solvency - Tuathail...................................................................................................... 71
16 purchases
0 comments
Updated
-
"The" PIC
By choopa
It's the argument you know and love - "The" PIC. This 30 page file has the 1NC, all link, impact, solvency and AT cards already pre-highlighted - this file is round ready. It includes a 2NC/1NR overview and a Theory Section. It's a classic and totally worth the investment.
“The†PIC Table of Contents
“The†PIC 1NC 3
2NC/1NR Overview 4
***LINKS 5
Discourse - Gikanda 6
Generic Extensions - Gogwilt 8
Generic Extensions - Shapiro 9
Threat Construction – Shapiro 10
Moral Obligation/Ethics - Shapiro 11
***IMPACTS 11
WAR! Impact 12
Homogenization Impact [1/2] 13
Homogenization Impact [2/2] 14
Capitalism Impact 15
Borders/State warfare Impact [1/2] 16
Borders/State warfare Impact [2/2] 17
***SOLVENCY 18
Generic Solvency [1/3] 19
Generic Solvency [2/3] 20
Generic Solvency [3/3] 21
Discourse Key 22
***THEORY 22
Severance Bad Theory 23
Conditionality Good Theory 24
Textual Competition Good Theory 25
***ANSWER TO SECTION 26
AT: Realism [1/2] 27
AT: Realism [2/2] 28
AT: State Good 29
AT: Permutation 30
5 purchases
0 comments
Updated
-
13 Military Presence Topic Word PICs ***PRICE REDUCED
Table of Contents
This file includes basically every Word PIC that is needed for the Military Presence topic. I included link evidence for 13 different Word PICs that are all topic specific. Additionally, the end of the file has some generic impact/perm cards that can be used. This file is useful in that the Word PIC is probably the hardest argument to answer. Additionally, this provides easy strategies to go for against almost every AFF. Finally, there is proven success with this file; I beat multiple TOC qualifiers with this file and had success at various national tournaments. Whoever buys this file is welcome to email me with questions on how to write blocks for this argument/how to deploy it in round.
17 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Increase PIC
By PKennedy
Table of Contents
This file is one of the more useful files on this topic, since everyone seems to have forgotten about it. When teams read affs that just remove a barrier, there is no reason they need to actually increase social services. So the trick to this argument is to PIC out of the increase in social services, read a DA, like politics with a spending link or just the economy DA, and then read topicality. They can't win the perm without being untopical, and they can't win T without conceding the perm. Either way, you are in a good strategic position, and take out the majority of their advantages, most likely all of them.
18 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Asylum Seekers CP/Refugee Flow Net Benefit
By PKennedy
Table of Contents
This counterplan was written against Carrollton's aff, though it could be used against any aff like it. It contains a pretty useful counterplan and net benefit against the aff. Its a must have if you find yourself without a strategy against teams that read this aff.
14 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
R&D PIC/Medicaid Neg
By PKennedy
Table of Contents
This is a tricky PIC that one of our teams deployed with great success. It's useful more generally than just a PIC, but it can be used against some Medicaid affs as a PIC. The basic argument is a DA about government funded R&D, versus privately funded R&D. It's a more theoretically sound version of the crowd-out DA that people have been running, though it has nothing to do with charities. Our team is the only one I can think of that's actually read this DA, so it could be very useful!
15 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Courts CP - Poverty Topic
By Kuntal
This is a blocked out Courts CP that works against all affs that either use another agent or don't specify. It includes:
- Very good generic solvency evidence for social services AND specific solvency cards for major affirmatives
- Well-developed competition frontline for affs that don't specify an agent
- Extensive frontlines to major responses, including solvency arguments and disadvantages to the CP
- A blocked out ASPEC violation to garner competition
- Theory frontlines
This counterplan works very well with politics as a net benefit - so it works in conjunction with the thursday file(s)
14 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Negotiation CP
By yackob87
Table of Contents
This was a strategy written for the toc that never got used in a big debate. This file contains a CP which uses the plan's incentives in international env and trade talks with sets of 3 net benefit arguments.1- Trade conflicts- incentives violate wto rules and cause them, the CP negotiates an international truce on ae incentives2- Copenhagen- the plan forfeits a bargaining chip that could be used to achieve real cuts at Copenhagen, the CP gets China to agree to cuts @ Copenhagen, the evidence that warming can't be solved without also getting China to reduce emissions is quite good3- Leadership- as i was looking for "prior key" cards i found some pretty good ev about why the us needs to take the initiative and resolve trade disputes on ae incentives before they start- the evidence argues this is important for 1- env leadership (1nc nb) 2- credibility/soft power 3- competitiveness (2nc nb with a trick against the perm)I should also mention most of the key solvency cards are 08 or 09- the best ones are from march and aprilThis file includes cards to make it relevant to the squirrely affirmatives that became more popular as the year went on and even more so at the toc including ev on- U tricks about incentives now/green stimulus- non-traditional ae- including new tech and nuke power- small procurement/military affsI think this could be deployed effectively at NFLs. Perhaps not with judges wary of any use of negative fiat but I think an argument that has an intuitive link to the plan (especially compared to most condition CPs) and will help you demonstrate that you are deeper on a pretty politically significant part of topic than the aff is something a lot of judges, even NFL judges, would like to see.
7 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Increase Justification
By PKennedy
Table of Contents
This is the oldest trick in the debate book, and I mean that almost literally. Justification is an extremely effective argument at the NFL tournament, as numerous previous years (including the NFL finals two years ago) prove. This argument is a theory argument and a counterplan rolled into one, and questions whether we really need to increase alternative energy incentives, or if we can just shift them from existing ineffective programs and save ourselves a bit of money/an unfortunate trade-off.
22 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Sino-Azerbaijani Conditioning CP
By PKennedy
Table of Contents
This is an effective generic argument to break out at NFL against the variety of new aff's that people will be pulling out. It includes a general theoretical defense of conditioning counterplans and
9 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Federalism Good
By Kuntal
The states counterplan will be a staple negative argument on this topic. This is a comprehensive federalism good impact file.
16 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Should PIC
By CubanRacer
Table of Contents
The word "should" presupposes a universal moral reality from which we can make accurate normative claims, causing terrorism and inter-state conflict. The counterplan replaces "should" with the statement "I favor," which clarifies the subjective nature of the value judgment. Unlike most other discourse PICs, this one actually has a solvency advocate - the author thinks that replacing "should" with "I favor" would change the way we think about morality. It's also very strong against K teams who you can pin down making moral claims in the 1AC or 1AC cross-ex.Includes full highlighting in gray, a 2NC overview, answers to aff arguments, and carded aff answers.
58 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
World Bank CP
By aimi
Table of Contents
This file has a bunch of solvency cards for a World Bank CP, including reasons why it solves poverty, agriculture, banks, disease, and water wars.
11 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Asian Monetary Fund
By aimi
Table of Contents
This is a counterplan that solves Asian and global financial crises through the setup of an Asian Monetary Fund. The file contains answers to every major disadvantage to this counterplan, as well as a number of offensive and defensive aff arguments. A great argument to read as an advantage CP, especially against a new aff.
4 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Specific Nondelegation Counterplan
Table of Contents
This isn't just a generic nondelegation cp. It has specific evidence dealing with all aspects of the topic, including specific solvency turns/net benefits. This is a fairly useful counterplan to carry around which you can read against any affirmative with delegated rulemaking. The counterplan has congress authorize the mandates of the plan through its nondelegated authority justified by the nondelegation doctrine. The counterplan solves the aff because it does the plan and has a couple net benefits including separation of powers, democracy, federalism, politics, and spending. This file comes with scripted 2NC/1NR blocks against every affirmative answer. It also has a load of affirmative answers. Also, most of the file is highlighted already and is ready to print and read. If you have any questions, feel free to ask. Jaipaulrekhi at gmail dot com.
12 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Consult Tribes CP
Table of Contents
This argument is a round winner against any Affirmative dealing with Native Americans. The Counterplan has the USFG enter into prior binding consultation with all relevant Native governments over the plan. Despite the fact that the counterplan would functionally result in the plan, meaning the case is solved, there are a couple of nuanced net benefits:1. Colonialism: The evidence indicates that the FG must consult genuinely and directly with Native Governments before decisions are made in order to protect sovereignty and ultimately solve the case. It argues that the unique legal status of tribes creates this requirement and failure to do so thwarts tribal sovereignty. There is an explicit link to the plan here: the plan’s failure to consult rationalizes hegemonic assertions of power that perpetuate the stranglehold of colonial oppression. The evidence is very specific in arguing that the counterplan is the only way to solve the root cause of this colonial stranglehold. 2. Homogenization: This argues that consulting Native governments individually is necessary because the affirmative homogenizes Indian country. It speaks to Native Americans through a monolithic voice. The subversion of the process of consultation obscures differences among tribes and reinforces the hostile forced assimilation of the past, turning the case. The evidence literally says that the counterplan is a “counter-hegemonic criticism” of the affirmatives homogenous gaze. This file comes with complete blocks, including the necessary analytical arguments, to all relevant affirmative responses. If you have any questions, feel free to ask me. My email is jaipaulrekhi at gmail dot com.
16 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
Russia Cooperation CP
By jmiller
This is a counterplan to any space affirmative. The text waives an act in the “Iran, North Korea, and Syria Nonproliferation Act” to allow international cooperation in space. Without international cooperation, the US cannot advance any of their space agenda. The CP text included is specific for Chattahoochee's affirmative - so you will need to adjust accordingly. The CP works best with a plan popular politics disad.
I'm going to try and put up a Russian Relations Impact File later on this weekend for supplement.
Index 0
Russian Coop CP – 1NC 1
Russian Coop CP – 2NC Overview 2
Russian Coop CP – 2NC Overview 3
Russian Coop CP – AT: Perm 4
Russian Coop CP – Solves Russian Relations 5
Russian Coop CP – US-Russia Relations Key -> Non Prolif 6
Russian Coop CP – US-Russia Relations Key -> Econ/Pol Stability 7
Russian Coop CP – US-Russia Relations Key -> Terr/Prolif 8
Russian Coop CP – US-Russia Relations Key -> Space Mil (1/2) 9
Russian Coop CP – US-Russia Relations Key -> Space Mil (2/2) 10
Russian Coop CP – Impact: US-Russian War 11
Russian Coop CP – Impact: Terrorism 12
Russian Coop CP – Impact: Terrorism 13
Russian Coop CP – CP Bipartisan 14
14 purchases
0 comments
Submitted
-
'Alternative' PIC
By dziegler
Table of Contents
This counterplan says to do the plan, but instead of using the word ‘alternative energy’, you should say ‘clean energy.’---“But hold up – my lab leader told me word PICs are dumb and only desperate teams use them!”Half-true. The argument is that the term ‘alternative’ is politically divisive – people read ‘alternative’ or ‘renewable’ and think hippy/pinko commie/lieberal (that’s right – lie-beral). The evidence is (surprisingly) pretty good that this has a psychological effect on people, and the shift to cleaner energy never happens. ‘Clean’ is a politically neutral word with no extra baggage that people are open to. The net benefit is pretty old school – you’re mutually exclusive with the plan and solve case better. More people are open to ‘clean energy.’ Everyone is using ‘alternative’ now, so you probably control the one-way uniqueness street on the framing of the energy debate. Game. Set. Match.---“Wait, this sounds shady. Those terrible lay judges that judge me will probably vote on the perm or theory or dumb defense args!”No worries. Scripted 2NC/1NR blocks have been written to every (half-intelligible) perm, theory, and defensive solvency claim you’re likely to hear.Have any questions, give me a yell. $5 is a steal for a stock argument you can use the entire year and even after. Alternative energy will be an issue in every debate in the near future.
1 purchase
0 comments
Submitted
-
'Alternative' PIC
By dziegler
Table of Contents
This counterplan says to do the plan, but instead of using the word ‘alternative energy’, you should say ‘clean energy.’---“But hold up – my lab leader told me word PICs are dumb and only desperate teams use them!”Half-true. The argument is that the term ‘alternative’ is politically divisive – people read ‘alternative’ or ‘renewable’ and think hippy/pinko commie/lieberal (that’s right – lie-beral). The evidence is (surprisingly) pretty good that this has a psychological effect on people, and the shift to cleaner energy never happens. ‘Clean’ is a politically neutral word with no extra baggage that people are open to. The net benefit is pretty old school – you’re mutually exclusive with the plan and solve case better. More people are open to ‘clean energy.’ Everyone is using ‘alternative’ now, so you probably control the one-way uniqueness street on the framing of the energy debate. Game. Set. Match.---“Wait, this sounds shady. Those terrible lay judges that judge me will probably vote on the perm or theory or dumb defense args!”No worries. Scripted 2NC/1NR blocks have been written to every (half-intelligible) perm, theory, and defensive solvency claim you’re likely to hear.Have any questions, give me a yell. $5 is a steal for a stock argument you can use the entire year and even after. Alternative energy will be an issue in every debate in the near future.
172 downloads
0 comments
Submitted
Sign in to follow this
Followers
0